Founder's Fortune: How Personality Shapes Startup Success

For many first-time founders, the path to a successful exit seems like a mixture of market timing, strategic decisions, and sometimes, a bit of luck.

Yet recent research published in the Scientific Reports journal challenges conventional wisdom by demonstrating that the personality traits of founders play a significant - and sometimes underestimated - role in determining startup success.

In this week’s briefing note, we explore the groundbreaking findings of this study entitled “The impact of founder personalities on startup success” and answer 3 key questions:

• Do founders of successful startups possess personality traits that differ significantly from the rest of the population?
• Are these traits more important than other factors in predicting startup success?
• How do investors assess these traits?

Rethinking Success: Beyond Conventional Wisdom

When we talk about startup success, the conversation often revolves around funding rounds, market strategy, and product-market fit. However, this revealing research based on an analysis of over 21,000 startups - uncovers a critical, underlying factor: the personality of the founder.

Utilising the ‘Big Five’ personality model, a widely respected framework for personality analysis, the researchers assessed founders across 30 dimensions. They discovered that certain traits are not only prevalent but also pivotal in steering a company toward success.

This insight challenges the conventional emphasis on external factors, suggesting that who a founder is can be as crucial as what they do. Its results reveal that “founder personality traits are a significant feature of a firm’s ultimate success” and that these traits markedly differ from those of the general population.

The Big Five Personality Traits

The Big Five Model, also known as the Five-Factor Model, is a widely recognised framework in psychology used to describe human personality. It encompasses five broad dimensions, often remembered by the acronym OCEAN:

• Openness to Experience: This trait features characteristics such as imagination and insight. Individuals high in openness tend to be more adventurous and creative, while those low in this trait may prefer routine and be more traditional in their thinking.
• Conscientiousness: This dimension includes high levels of thoughtfulness, good impulse control, and goal-directed behaviours. Highly conscientious individuals are organised and mindful of details.
• Extraversion: Extraversion is characterised by excitability, sociability, talkativeness, assertiveness, and high amounts of emotional expressiveness. Extraverts are outgoing and tend to gain energy in social situations.
• Agreeableness: This personality dimension includes attributes such as trust, altruism, kindness, and affection. Agreeable individuals are cooperative and get along well with others.
• Neuroticism: Neuroticism refers to the tendency to experience negative emotions, such as anger, anxiety, or depression. Individuals high in this trait may be more prone to stress and emotional instability.

The use of the Big Five Model in this research provided a structured and empirically validated approach to quantify and analyse the complex interplay between founder personalities and startup outcomes.

The study identifies several key personality facets that distinguish successful entrepreneurs:

• Adventurousness (Openness to Experience): A strong preference for variety, novelty, and initiating new ventures. This trait aligns seamlessly with the dynamic and uncertain nature of startups, where embracing new ideas and taking calculated risks are essential.
• Lower Modesty (Agreeableness): Successful founders often exhibit lower levels of modesty, displaying a willingness to be the centre of attention and assert their vision boldly. This self-assuredness can be advantageous in leading a company and inspiring confidence among stakeholders.
• High Activity Level (Extraversion): Elevated energy and enthusiasm are common among successful founders. This vigour not only propels innovation but also motivates teams and attracts investors, creating a dynamic organisational culture.

These traits collectively contribute to a founder’s ability to navigate the challenges of the startup world, suggesting that personal characteristics can significantly impact business outcomes.

Beyond One-Size-Fits-All: Six Distinct Founder Types

While the Big Five provides a broad framework for understanding personality, the research also identified six distinct personality types among successful startup founders:

• Fighters: Characterised by high levels of emotional range, including traits such as anger, anxiety, and vulnerability.
• Operators: Noted for high conscientiousness, particularly in orderliness, and high agreeableness, especially in humility.
• Accomplishers: Exhibit high extraversion across all facets and high conscientiousness in several facets.
• Leaders: Display high openness, especially in artistic interests and emotionality, and high agreeableness in facets like altruism and sympathy.
• Engineers: Highest in openness, particularly in imagination and intellect.
• Developers: Considered the “middle child” cluster, sharing characteristics similar to Fighters but with higher extraversion.

Interestingly, the research suggests that there is no single “ideal” founder personality. Instead, successful startups often have diverse founding teams with complementary personality types. This “Ensemble Theory of Success” highlights the importance of a balanced team where different strengths and perspectives contribute to a greater chance of achieving a successful outcome.

The Role of Founder Personality in Startup Success

To understand the weight of personality traits relative to other factors, the study conducted a multi-factor analysis incorporating variables such as location, industry, company age, and team size.

The findings reveal that personality characteristics hold significant predictive power regarding a startup’s likelihood of a successful exit, whether through acquisition, trade sale, or IPO.

For example, a founder’s personality was found to be more predictive of success than the industry the startup operates in (5 times) and the age of the startup (2 times).

By accurately predicting entrepreneurial status from personality data alone - with an accuracy rate exceeding 82% - the study reinforces the notion that “founder personalities matter”.

This predictive capability implies that, in many cases, personality traits can be as important as, if not more important than, many external factors in determining startup success.

Why Personality Trumps Conventional Metrics

This research invites a re-evaluation of the traditional emphasis on business models and market strategies by highlighting the intrinsic value of founder personalities:

• Complementary Teams: Startups with founding teams that exhibit a diversity of personality types tend to have higher success rates. The interplay of different traits - such as pairing an adventurous leader with a detail-oriented accomplisher - can foster innovation and resilience, enabling the team to navigate uncertainties more effectively.
• Intrinsic Predictors of Success: Unlike external factors like market dynamics and funding, personality traits remain relatively stable over time, even through significant life events. This stability means that the inherent qualities of founders can consistently influence outcomes, providing a reliable foundation for decision-making and leadership.
• Beyond the Obvious: While broad traits like resilience and risk tolerance are often highlighted, this study offers a nuanced perspective by examining specific facets such as adventurousness and activity level. These granular insights reveal that particular aspects of a founder’s personality are more predictive of success than previously understood.

By focusing on these intrinsic factors, the study suggests that developing and leveraging certain personality traits can be as crucial, if not more so than traditional metrics, in determining startup success.

Developing the Right Traits for Startup Success

While some individuals may naturally possess the personality traits associated with successful founders, these characteristics can also be developed and nurtured over time. This may elevate the success potential for first time founders in particular.

First-time founders should therefore focus on:

• Investing in Personal Growth: Recognising that traits such as adventurousness and assertiveness can significantly influence success, founders might consider personal development and coaching to cultivate these attributes.
• Building Diverse Teams: Understanding that no single personality type guarantees success, but that a diverse combination can create a powerful synergy, founders should be strategic about team composition. Seeking partners who complement their strengths and counterbalance their weaknesses can enhance the team’s overall effectiveness.
• Embracing Your Uniqueness: While conventional wisdom often champions humility and caution, the research suggests that a certain level of self-assuredness - even if it means exhibiting lower modesty - can be beneficial in the high-stakes world of startups. Founders should feel empowered to embrace their unique traits and leverage them as assets in their entrepreneurial journey.
  
  For investors and advisors, the findings underscore the value of incorporating personality assessments into due diligence processes. It could be that the next great startup isn’t solely defined by its product or market strategy but by the unique personality mix of its founding team.

Looking Ahead: Integrating Personality into the Startup Ecosystem

The insights from this study invite us to reimagine how success is cultivated in the startup ecosystem.
For founders, this means recognising and harnessing one’s innate traits as a cornerstone of the business strategy.

For investors and corporate finance advisors, the research opens the door to more nuanced evaluation criteria that go beyond balance sheets and business models.

By integrating personality assessments into the early stages of startup evaluation, stakeholders can gain a clearer picture of a founder’s potential to steer the company through turbulent times.

While it’s true that VCs recognise the importance of founder personality in their investment decisions, today few rely on formal personality tests like Myers-Briggs. Instead, they tend to employ a more intuitive approach, honed through years of experience evaluating entrepreneurs.

This involves observing founders in various settings, such as pitch meetings and due diligence sessions, to assess their character and leadership potential. VCs often look for specific attributes that create a positive impression and signal a founder’s likelihood of success. These include:

• Clarity of thought and communication: Can the founder articulate their vision and business model in a clear and concise manner?
• Intellectual integrity and self-awareness: Does the founder demonstrate a willingness to learn, adapt, and acknowledge their own strengths and weaknesses?
• Passion and commitment: Is the founder genuinely passionate about their venture and committed to its long-term success?
• Resilience and a solution-oriented mindset: Can the founder navigate challenges with a positive attitude and a focus on finding solutions?
• Ambition and a desire to scale: Does the founder possess the drive and ambition to grow their venture into a significant player in the market?
• Results-oriented focus: Does the founder prioritise achieving measurable outcomes and demonstrate a history of delivering on their commitments?
• Humility and coachability: Is the founder open to feedback and willing to learn from others?

By observing these attributes, VCs can gain a sense of a founder’s character, leadership potential, and overall fit for the challenges of building a successful startup.

This intuitive assessment, combined with an evaluation of the business opportunity itself, now routinely forms the basis of investment decisions.

Conclusion: The Person Behind the Innovation

While personality traits are not the sole determinant of startup success, they undoubtedly play a significant role in shaping a founder’s journey. By understanding the characteristics that often distinguish successful entrepreneurs, first-time founders in particular can gain valuable self-awareness and identify areas for personal development.

Cultivating resilience, adaptability, and strong communication skills, alongside a willingness to embrace new experiences and challenges, can significantly increase the likelihood of achieving a successful exit.

The “Ensemble Theory of Success” highlights the importance of building a diverse founding team with complementary personality types. This approach can help founders create a balanced and dynamic team that is better equipped to navigate the challenges of the startup world.

Crucially, understanding the importance of personality can help founders attract investors, as research shows that venture capitalists increasingly rely on personality assessments (both formal and informal) when making investment decisions.

As a first-time founder, take the time to reflect on your own personality traits and consider how you can develop the characteristics that contribute to startup success. Embrace your strengths, address your weaknesses, and surround yourself with a team that complements your skills and personality.
By doing so, you can increase your chances of achieving your entrepreneurial dreams.

Let's talk.